The article is courtesy of our friends at Bleacher Nation
Written by: Brett Taylor
The much-discussed hopes of acquiring 22-year-old first base prospect Anthony Rizzo from
the Padres has finally been accomplished. Today the Cubs announced that they’ve acquired
Rizzo, together with pitcher Zach Cates for pitcher Andrew Cashner and outfield prospect
Rizzo has been discussed here at length before, but here’s a notable selection:
Rizzo, who just turned 22 in August, is the top prospect in a very, very good Padres’ system. Rizzo was a top 100 prospect in all of baseball going into 2011, and then all he did was put up an eye-popping .331/.404/.652 line, with 26 homers and 34 doubles in just 93 games. Those numbers are great even for the PCL, particularly for a 21-year-old. Before 2011, Rizzo’s minor league numbers were good, if unremarkable, but he was young at every level, and was consistent after each promotion. Rizzo is also believed to be an above average
defender at first base.
Rizzo was called up late last year for a cup of coffee, and struggled mightily, hitting just .141/.281/.252 in 153 plate appearances (love that IsoD, though, eh?). Very few saw that as a reason for concern, however.
Rizzo was drafted by the Red Sox under Theo Epstein, Jed Hoyer and Jason McLeod, so
their interest is, of course, understandable. Given his age and lack of success in the bigs
last year, it wouldn’t be surprising to see the Cubs let Bryan LaHair break camp as the
Cubs’ starting first baseman, giving Rizzo additional time to develop at AAA. Otherwise,
Rizzo is the Cubs’ starting first baseman right out of the gate, and, yes, almost certainly
takes the Cubs out of the running for Prince Fielder.
Cates, 22, was the Padres’ 3rd round pick in 2010 (again, Hoyer/McLeod), and spent 2011
in A ball, pitching adequately, if unspectacularly.
Cates is probably a fair swap for Na, 20, who is himself a legit prospect. A quality young
outfielder, Na has a great deal of upside, but is still a long way from the Majors. Given the
Cubs’ depth in low-minors outfield prospects, Na was expendable.
And, ah, Andrew Cashner.
Going into 2011, he was primed for a breakout season in the rotation. His first start didn’t
disappoint – or, at least, it wouldn’t have, if it hadn’t been his only start. Recurrent rotator cuff
issues ended Cashner’s season, and he was set to pitch out of the pen in 2012. To be sure,
Cashner is an extremely talented pitcher, but, given the injuries and the likelihood he’d be in
the pen in the near-term, he was a piece the Cubs could afford to shop. If Cates is a fair
swap with Na, landing Rizzo for Cashner is likewise a fair move.
Given the Cubs’ long-term needs, and the relative depth of their pen, I can’t call this anything
but a win for the Cubs. It was probably also a win for the Padres, which is just fine with me.
Obviously I’ll have much, much more on this trade in the coming days.